About the song
“Carlisle Wheeling” (the first recorded version) from The Monkees’ 1967 album Headquarters is a track that reflects a departure from the band’s typical pop sound and shows their musical versatility. Written by Michael Nesmith, the song has country and folk influences, which was somewhat unusual for The Monkees, who were primarily known for their pop rock hits. In this early version, “Carlisle Wheeling” captures a mellow, reflective vibe, showcasing Nesmith’s ability to incorporate his love for country music and storytelling into the band’s musical repertoire.
The song opens with a soft acoustic guitar intro, setting the tone for a country-tinged ballad. The arrangement is simple but effective, with light percussion and harmonized vocals that give the track a sense of depth and emotion. Micky Dolenz and Davy Jones provide vocal harmonies, giving the song a feeling of togetherness and support. Nesmith’s voice leads the song with a gentle delivery, reflecting the reflective nature of the lyrics. The soft, rhythmic guitar, paired with Dolenz’s distinct vocal quality, gives the track an overall sense of warmth and authenticity.
Lyrically, “Carlisle Wheeling” tells a story of longing and loss, as the narrator reflects on a past relationship and the distance between him and his loved one. The title, “Carlisle Wheeling”, refers to two cities in Pennsylvania, adding to the song’s sense of nostalgia and remembrance. The song’s lyrics are poetic and simple, with a focus on the emotional complexities of love and the passage of time.
Though this first recorded version of “Carlisle Wheeling” wasn’t one of The Monkees’ big commercial hits, it stands out as an early example of Nesmith’s ability to bring a country influence into the band’s music. It also reflects the growing sense of artistic freedom the band was beginning to embrace during the recording of Headquarters, a period in which they took more creative control over their music.
Ultimately, “Carlisle Wheeling” remains a hidden gem in The Monkees’ catalog, loved by fans who appreciate the band’s ability to experiment with different genres. It’s a soft, reflective song that highlights the band’s musical range and artistic growth, showing their versatility and willingness to explore new sounds. Whether heard for its country-folk influences or its lyrical depth, it is a track that offers a glimpse into The Monkees’ broader musical landscape beyond their pop and rock hits.