About the song
As The Monkees evolved from a bubblegum pop band into a more serious and musically ambitious group, their 1968 album Headquarters marked a turning point in their career. Among the standout tracks on the album is the introspective and emotionally resonant “Hard to Believe”. While The Monkees had already proven their ability to craft catchy, upbeat tunes, “Hard to Believe” gave listeners a glimpse into their growing sophistication as artists. Written by Monkees member Peter Tork along with Jeff Barry and Jerry Leiber, this song offers a contrast to the band’s earlier work, shifting toward deeper, more personal lyrical themes and a more complex musical arrangement.
In many ways, “Hard to Believe” is a reflection of The Monkees’ growth as musicians and songwriters. The track departs from the lighthearted, carefree spirit that characterized much of their earlier material and introduces a more thoughtful, mature approach to songwriting. The lyrics themselves are imbued with a sense of nostalgia and regret, expressing feelings of disbelief and introspection, which resonate with anyone who has experienced the bittersweet passage of time. The refrain “It’s hard to believe, but it’s true” encapsulates the emotional tone of the song, which, despite its melancholic undertones, never becomes overly sentimental.
Musically, “Hard to Believe” demonstrates The Monkees’ increasing musical depth. The track incorporates folk and rock elements, which were becoming more prevalent in popular music during the late 1960s. The arrangement is stripped back compared to some of their earlier hits, allowing the emotive vocals and acoustic instrumentation to take center stage. This simplicity is deliberate, letting the rawness of the lyrics shine through, while still maintaining that signature Monkees charm. The harmonies, too, are a crucial aspect of the song’s emotional impact. Their voices blend seamlessly, lending an air of authenticity and vulnerability that makes the song feel deeply personal.
“Hard to Believe” is also notable for its minimalist yet powerful instrumentation, with a focus on acoustic guitar and subtle keyboard flourishes, enhancing the song’s reflective mood. The arrangement allows the song to breathe and gives space for the listener to take in the message. Unlike many pop songs of the era, which were often densely layered with production, “Hard to Believe” feels intimate and raw, offering an insight into the band’s evolving artistic vision.
While “Hard to Believe” may not have garnered the same level of commercial success as some of their other hits, it holds a special place in The Monkees’ discography as a reflection of their versatility as artists. It’s a track that offers a more nuanced look at their sound, balancing emotional depth with musical restraint. For those familiar with The Monkees’ early hits, “Hard to Believe” serves as a reminder that beneath their catchy melodies and infectious energy, there was always a deeper, more reflective side to their artistry.
For listeners who may have initially dismissed The Monkees as a lighthearted pop group, “Hard to Believe” stands as a testament to their musical maturity and their ability to craft songs with emotional resonance and lasting appeal. The song’s blend of vulnerability, heartfelt lyrics, and understated instrumentation marks an important chapter in The Monkees’ musical journey and continues to resonate with those who appreciate thoughtful, introspective music. It’s a powerful reminder that even within a pop band known for its fun and catchy hits, there’s always room for reflection, growth, and profound musical moments.