Beyoncé’s historic Grammy win for Best Country Album with “Cowboy Carter” was a groundbreaking moment. She became the first Black woman to win in this category, which is certainly a notable achievement. However, her victory sparked controversy and overshadowed deserving country artists who had dedicated their careers to the genre. Critics argue that Beyoncé’s win came at the expense of artists who, in any other year, would have had a fair shot at the Grammy for Best Country Album.
Beyoncé’s Victory and the Backlash
Beyoncé herself admitted that “Cowboy Carter” was not a country album, which made the decision even more puzzling to many fans and artists alike. The win was seen by some as a manufactured moment, aimed at creating a viral sensation, rather than a reflection of true achievement in the country genre. While Beyoncé’s talent and influence are undeniable, many believed the Best Country Album category should have honored artists who have consistently contributed to the heart and soul of country music.
The Country Artists Who Should Have Won
Let’s take a look at the country artists who were unfairly sidelined in favor of a pop superstar’s Grammy victory.
Kacey Musgraves – Deeper Well
Kacey Musgraves is no stranger to the Grammy stage, having won Best Country Album twice before. Her latest project, “Deeper Well,” was lauded for its introspective songwriting and lush production. Musgraves’ music stays true to the storytelling heart of country music, making her a strong contender for the award. While she did win Best Country Song for “The Architect,” many believed Deeper Well should have also taken home Best Country Album.
When Beyoncé’s name was announced, Musgraves’ reaction was captured and turned into a meme—widely interpreted as disappointment. Given Musgraves’ contribution to country music, it’s hard to blame her.
Chris Stapleton – Higher
Chris Stapleton, a consistent Grammy favorite and one of country’s most beloved voices, was another strong contender. His album “Higher” blended blues, country, and rock, staying true to the authenticity that the genre prides itself on. Stapleton took home Best Country Solo Performance for “It Takes a Woman,” but the loss for Best Country Album to an artist who didn’t embrace the genre was hard to digest for fans and critics alike.
Lainey Wilson – Whirlwind
Lainey Wilson has quickly become a rising star in country music. With her blend of modern and traditional sounds, Wilson’s album “Whirlwind” was expected to be a serious contender. Her authentic love for country music and ability to connect with fans made her an ideal candidate for recognition. However, the Grammys chose celebrity over substance, sending a message that even the most promising new stars in the genre may not stand a chance when a pop icon decides to “experiment” with country music for an album cycle.
Post Malone – F-1 Trillion
The inclusion of Post Malone’s “F-1 Trillion” in the country category raised many eyebrows, especially considering the backlash surrounding “Cowboy Carter.” But here’s the truth: Post Malone’s album was likely more country than Beyoncé’s. His work, while blending elements of other genres, had a much deeper connection to the country roots than Beyoncé’s pop-infused project. If anything, it was a reminder that the Grammys should be recognizing artists whose work is rooted in the genre, not just those who dip their toes into it for the sake of cross-genre experimentation.
The Bigger Issue: The Grammys and Country Music
Beyoncé’s win for Best Country Album highlights the ongoing issue of mainstream awards shows blurring the lines between genres and, in some cases, diminishing the efforts of true country artists. While the Grammys celebrated Beyoncé’s achievement, it also pushed aside artists who have been dedicating their careers to keeping the spirit of country music alive.
As the country music industry continues to evolve, there’s hope that future awards will prioritize authentic country talent—artists who have devoted themselves to the genre, telling real country stories, and staying true to its roots.
Videos